MLB Rumors: Juan Soto’s Shortcomings Highlighted Again After Yankees’ AL Rival Plans a Shocking Positional Change

The Boston Red Sox are reportedly after one of the biggest prizes on the free agent market: Juan Soto. The 26-year-old slugger, who has already got five Silver Sluggers, a Rookie of the Year award, and four All-Star selections in just seven seasons, is to be the center of this winter's free agency. After a career year with the New York Yankees, Soto could be the transformative player Boston needs.

For the Red Sox, the acquisition of Juan Soto would be a game-changer, particularly in terms of lineup protection for Rafael Devers. Since the departures of Mookie Betts, Xander Bogaerts, and J.D. Martinez, Devers has often been forced to carry the offensive load on his own. Soto would immediately provide the perfect complement to Devers.

The Red Sox's probable plans for Juan Soto Juan Soto's bat is undoubtedly elite, but there is some concern about his defense, particularly at Fenway Park. According to the Boston Globe , while Soto was a Gold Glove finalist in right field with the Yankees, his defensive metrics have been somewhat underwhelming. He has just one defensive run saved (DRS) in 2024. He has had occasional misplays in right field, and being inconsistent in handling balls hit to the gaps. That forced the Yankees to move Aaron Judge to center field in order to minimize Soto's defensive liabilities.

Fenway's quirky dimensions, especially in right field, where the wall looms just 302 feet away could present challenges for Soto. More so if he's asked to play out there regularly. The Red Sox might view him as more of a designated hitter, where his bat would provide maximum value while minimizing the impact of his defense. It's a trade-off worth making if it means locking down one of the most dangerous hitters in the game.

What could the contract with the Red Sox look like? Of course, landing a player of Soto's caliber will come at a high price. His contract could rival some of the largest deals in MLB history. His deal could likely exceed $300 million for a long-term extension. The Red Sox are reportedly ready to spend big this offseason. However, adding Soto wouldn't just require cash.

The Red Sox could look to move some players to balance the books, particularly if they pull off a trade for White Sox starter Garrett Crochet, as has been rumored. To land Soto, Boston may need to part with a top pitching prospect or even a young player like outfielder Wilyer Abreu. Abreu had a strong season, winning a Gold Glove in right field. Despite the defensive questions, Juan Soto remains one of the most sought-after talents in baseball.