Farmers Threaten ‘Militant’ Action on Inheritance Tax Change
The head of the National Farmers' Union (NFU) has said farmers are ready to take "militant" action after meeting the government to urge a U-turn on planned changes to inheritance tax.
NFU President Tom Bradshaw said he had never seen "the weight of support, the strength of feeling and anger" over the plans to impose inheritance tax on farms worth more than £1 million, which farmers have said could spell the end for family farming in the UK.
Under plans announced in last week's Budget, agricultural property relief (APR) will be scrapped, so tax will be levied at 20 percent on farms worth more than £1 million. Farmers have said it will force their families to sell off the land they inherit in order to settle the tax bill.
But speaking on Monday after a meeting with Environment Secretary Steve Reed and Exchequer Secretary to the Treasury James Murray, Bradshaw challenged the claim that only a minority of farms would be subject to the tax.
He told the PA news agency: "Obviously, we fully dispute the figures the Treasury has been using and we've played back DEFRA's [Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs] own figures.
"So, the Treasury is saying only 27 percent of farms will be within scope of these changes, DEFRA's own figures suggest that two-thirds of farms will be in scope.
"How they can have that wide a discrepancy within government is quite unbelievable."
He said there had been no resolution on the issue, adding: "We've made very passionately our perception clear, that this tax change is completely unfair.
"It had been ruled out by the secretary of state in the run-up to the election and now there are many family farms right across the United Kingdom that are worried for their future."
People commonly avoid inheritance tax through a transfer of assets to the next generation, but this must be done at least seven years before death.
Bradshaw said he had spoken to farmers in their middle age who have been running successful businesses, but whose parents were still in the family house and remain partners in the business and who may not live for another seven years.
He said: "We will continue to try and work with the government to get to a resolution but something has to change.
"I have never seen the weight of support, the strength of feeling and anger that there is in this industry today. Many of them want to be militant."
He did not elaborate on what "militant" action might look like, but in online forums, farmers have been discussing a "sewage strike" where they could potentially stop taking sludge from water companies to use as fertilizer.
Although farming does not have a history of widespread strike action in the UK, farmers have taken part in organised protests, such as in 2013, when they lobbied against proposed changes to EU agricultural subsidies and the Common Agricultural Policy.
Reeves told the BBC's "Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg" on Nov. 3: "Only a very small number of agricultural properties will be affected, but last year the benefits of agricultural property relief, 40 percent of the benefit was felt by 7 percent of the wealthiest land owners.
Following the meeting, the government continued to insist the vast majority of farmers will still be able to pass on the family farm to their children.
Speaking in a House of Commons debate on Monday afternoon, minister for food security and rural affairs Daniel Zeichner referred again to a "£22 billion black hole" which Labour says the previous Conservative government left in the public finances.
He said: "We completely understand farmers' anxieties about the changes, but rural communities need a better NHS, affordable housing, and public transport, and we can provide that if we make the system fairer.
"The reforms [to APR] mean that farmers can access 100 percent relief for the first £1 million and 50 percent relief thereafter—an effective 20 percent tax rate. That means that an individual can pass up to £2 million, and a couple up to £3 million between them, to a direct descendant, inheritance tax-free."
The government has said that a small number of wealthy landowners who are not actually farmers, but who register as having a farming business, have been using APR to avoid paying inheritance tax.
"Agricultural property relief is not a loophole; it has been a deliberate policy of successive governments for the past 40 years, designed to avoid the sale and break-up of family farms," he said.
Former Tory minister Kevin Hollinrake branded the policy ideologically driven and "warped."
He told MPs: "The only transition [farmers] can see is transition from family farms to the state. Does he realise that the farming industry is one of the least profitable sectors in the country?
Ann Davies, an MP for Welsh nationalist party Plaid Cymru and a tenant dairy farmer, accused the government of trying "to portray farming as an industry of super-wealthy landowners," which she said is "simply not the case in Wales."
"Welsh upland farmers in mountainous and hilly areas have an average annual income of £18,600—yes, you heard correctly: £18,600. That is far below the national living wage for hours that are way beyond the average 40-hour week," she said.
But Zeichner said the likely outcome of the change will be that, "People will put arrangements in place to pass on their farms at the appropriate time, pulling more younger people into farming, which will be a good thing."
