The Bold and the Beautiful Star Annika Noelle and Actor John Patrick Amedori Are Engaged: 'A Love That Grows Every Day' (Exclusive)

John Patrick Amedori and Annika Noelle are engaged !

The Dear White People actor, 37, popped the question to the soap star, also 37, in October during a romantic proposal at a place which "holds a special meaning to us," they tell PEOPLE.

"He planned an entire day, full of activities that reflected the journey of our relationship thus far. From the experiences, to the food, to the music, it was incredibly thoughtful and personal to us," says Noelle, who has played Hope Logan in The Bold and the Beautiful since 2018.

As for Noelle's engagement ring, Amedori explains that he wanted "something elegant and classic that would also complement the future wedding bands we will be designing together."

Adds Noelle, "I wasn't the only one who got a ring," referring to the signet-style jewelry piece she gave to Amedori for the occasion.

Following the proposal, the couple celebrated the moment by driving to see their "favorite crooner," Douglas Roegiers. "[Roegiers] dedicated a song just for us two on our special night, and we spent the evening dancing," the actress says.

Now, the pair are looking forward to planning a wedding together. "I'm elated," Amedori says of the prospect of marrying Noelle. "I fall more and more in love every day. It really is wild how quickly life can change for the better when you meet your person."

The two first met at Luna Luna, an exhibition in Los Angeles showcasing the world's first art amusement park. "Ironically, there was an interactive piece where they asked us if we wanted to get married. Little did we know..." Noelle recalls.

She says finding love "wasn't something we were expecting. But it was something we recognized very quickly. A kinship, a respect, a trust and a love that grows every day."

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Amedori — who, in addition to acting, is a musician who writes original songs for TV and film — tells PEOPLE he "couldn't have fathomed [finding] a stronger, more beautiful soul" than Noelle.

"From the moment I met her, I knew there was no hiding," he explains. "She encourages one to be their truest self. She also has great taste in music."

Noelle cited Amedori's "kind heart," "quick wit" and "listening ear" as some of the qualities she loves most about her future husband.

"I am constantly in awe of his talent. He is so multifaceted, plus he makes me laugh," she says, adding, "He's a keeper."

Noelle recently shared her support for Amedori on Instagram , posting clips from his various acting roles over the years, as she celebrated his latest role in the Starz series Three Women.

"When you swore you'd never date an actor but now get to watch him grow up on screen," the two-time Daytime Emmy Award nominee wrote in text over the video. "I get to witness his talent and years of dedication ... I cannot wait to watch what comes next."