What Exactly Is Digital Evidence?

In the quiet heart of Wichita, Kansas, a chilling shadow lingered for over three decades. Dennis Rader , infamously known as BTK—short for Bind, Torture, Kill—haunted the community with a spree of heinous murders between 1974 and 1991. His calculated crimes and cryptic communication with law enforcement left a city paralyzed with fear and a trail of cold cases that baffled investigators.

Few cases in criminal history highlight the power of digital evidence as poignantly as the eventual capture of Rader. After years of silence, Rader resurfaced in 2005, sending a floppy disk to law enforcement in an attempt to mock them. Unbeknownst to him, the disk contained metadata that linked it to a computer at Christ Lutheran Church in Wichita, where Rader served as a leader. Investigators identified a critical detail: the document was last modified by a user named "Dennis," unraveling his carefully maintained anonymity.

This turning point showcased the transformative potential of digital forensics, a discipline that exposed a notorious killer and demonstrated the vulnerabilities of those who underestimate technology's ability to uncover the truth. The BTK case became a defining moment in forensic science, heralding a new era where digital footprints often speak louder than words. As an expert in digital forensics , I have witnesses firsthand the incessant march forward in complexity and quantity of digital devices and data—and it is not slowing down.

What is Digital Evidence?

Digital evidence refers to data and information stored, transmitted, or received by an electronic device that can be used as evidence in an investigation. This evidence is crucial in both criminal and civil cases, similar to traditional evidence such as fingerprints or eyewitness testimony, but it exists in digital format.

Digital evidence can take many forms, including text messages, emails, digital photos and videos, call logs, GPS data, web browsing history, health data and social media interactions. It is stored on various digital devices such as cellphones, computers, tablets, digital cameras, fitness wearables, smartwatches and cloud storage services.

Unlike traditional forensic evidence, which involves the physical examination of objects, digital evidence requires specific tools and expertise to access, analyze and interpret. Devices like phones or computers act as containers for evidence rather than as the evidence itself.

Digital Forensics Reignites 2019 Cold Case Murder Of Kimberly Bell The Nature of Digital Evidence

Digital evidence is different from traditional physical evidence in several ways. In traditional forensic sciences, physical objects are directly examined as evidence, such as a vehicle crash or a crime scene littered with shell casings. These objects tell a story through their physical characteristics, modifications and positions within the scene. They can be physically handled, observed with the naked eye, and analyzed through direct interaction with the material substance of the evidence.

On the other hand, in the digital realm, devices like phones or computers act as containers for evidence rather than as the evidence themselves. While you may document the fact that a cellphone screen was damaged or that the serial number on a hard drive was scratched off, this is only a surface-level view of the evidence—literally.

While traditional evidence is about the physical examination of objects involved in an incident, digital evidence examines the virtual world contained within electronic devices. These devices serve as vessels, carrying rich, detailed accounts of personal and professional activities that are crucial for forensic investigations and legal proceedings. Data stored within these devices, such as texts, emails, images, logs, and other digital files is the actual evidence. This data exists in a state that requires specialized tools and knowledge to interpret and often provides a detailed and often incontrovertible account of activities, communications and transactions.

Digital evidence is like a black box in an airplane. The box contains vital information about the plane's flight, including conversations in the cockpit, altitude changes, and other data that can help explain what happens if the plane crashes. Similarly, digital devices like phones and computers act as black boxes containing information that can help explain what happened in a particular case. The data stored within these devices can offer insights into behaviors, locations, and interactions that are pertinent to a case, just as the black box can offer insights into what happened during a flight.

Protecting Digital Evidence

Protecting digital evidence is critical to ensure its integrity, authenticity, and reliability. The value of digital evidence in litigation and investigations hinges on its ability to withstand legal scrutiny regarding these aspects. Since digital evidence is intangible, it can be easily altered or manipulated, which can compromise its credibility. Therefore, strict protocols must be followed for collection, preservation, and analysis.

Digital evidence must be gathered in a way that ensures its integrity, meaning that the data collected is a true and accurate representation of the original information. This involves using specialized techniques and tools that prevent the data from being altered or damaged during the collection process.

Think That Screenshot Is Proof? Here's Why It Might Not Hold Up In Court

Once the data has been collected, it must be preserved in a secure and controlled environment to ensure that it remains unchanged until it is presented in court. This means that it must be stored in a way that prevents unauthorized access, and the chain of custody must be carefully documented to show who has had access to it and when.

Finally, digital evidence must be analyzed and interpreted by experts who can clearly and accurately explain its meaning and relevance to the case. This requires specialized knowledge and training in digital forensics and an understanding of the legal context in which the evidence is being presented.

Overall, the value of digital evidence in court depends on its ability to be verified as authentic and reliable through strict adherence to protocols for its collection, preservation, and analysis. Ensuring the integrity of digital evidence can provide critical insights into a case and help establish the facts that ultimately determine its outcome.

Can Expert Witnesses Use AI? Key Takeaways: Digital Evidence