Hollywood’s Silent Stars: How the Talmadge Sisters Left Their Mark on San Diego Streets

Tucked away in mid-city San Diego lies a neighborhood with a unique historical touch. Developed in the 1920s, Talmadge pays tribute to these silent film icons: Norma, Constance, Natalie, and Agnes Talmadge. While the sisters may not be as well-known today, their legacy lives on through the streets that bear their names.

Constance, Norma, Natalie Drives, and Agnes Avenue serve as quiet reminders of these early movie stars, connecting the charm of Hollywood's golden age to everyday life in this Southern California community.

Laura Henson, president of the Talmadge Historical Society, explains the neighborhood's origins: "Roy Litchy and his brother Guy were San Diego realtors who decided to get into land development in the mid-1920s. Roy lived in Los Angeles and played golf with Hollywood movie executives, asking them if they were interested in investing in San Diego real estate. Some of his investors included Joseph Schenck , silent screen star Buster Keaton, and Louis B. Mayer."

Who Were the Talmadge Sisters?

In the early 20th century, the Talmadge sisters were Hollywood stars, each forging a unique career path.

Embed from

While Constance, Natalie, and Agnes Talmadge have their place in history, Norma Talmadge was by far the most famous of the sisters. Known as one of the great silent film actresses, Norma starred in over 80 films and was revered for her dramatic roles. Her performances in films like Smilin' Through (1922) and The Lady (1925) cemented her reputation as one of the finest actresses of the silent era.

Norma's rise to stardom was swift and extraordinary. Born in Jersey City in 1894, she entered the film industry at a young age and quickly captured the attention of audiences and directors alike. Her ability to convey emotion without sound made her an exceptional talent in silent films, where facial expressions and physical acting were paramount. Director D.W. Griffith once called her "the queen of silent cinema," a testament to her immense influence in the industry ( Classic Hollywood Quotes ).

Despite her early success, Norma Talmadge's career dwindled with the advent of "talkies." Like many silent film stars, the transition to sound proved difficult, and by the early 1930s, she had retired from acting. However, her legacy endured, and her name lives on in San Diego's Talmadge neighborhood, where "Norma Drive" runs parallel to streets named after her sisters.

Local film historian Joe Grant explained, "Norma Talmadge was a powerhouse in her time. Her films were some of the most critically acclaimed of the silent era, and having a street named after her in San Diego is a fitting tribute to one of Hollywood's early legends" ( San Diego Film Archives ).

Constance Talmadge became famous as a comedic actress in films like The Honeymoon (1917) and Her Night of Romance (1924). Known for her lighthearted approach, she once said, "I don't take life seriously, and I don't take acting seriously. It's all a lot of fun" (Classic Movie Blog). Her carefree attitude made her a beloved figure during the silent film era.

Natalie Talmadge , though less prolific, gained attention for her marriage to legendary silent film star Buster Keaton. She once remarked, "Hollywood isn't kind to everyone. You either find yourself or you lose yourself" (Hollywood Archives), a reflection of the industry's pressures. Despite her brief career, her legacy remains tied to Keaton.

Embed from

Agnes Talmadge, the eldest, took on more supporting roles, allowing her younger sisters to shine.

Henson adds, "The Talmadge Sisters attended the dedication ceremony for the Talmadge Park Unit 1 subdivision on January 3, 1926, planting a tree at the end of Adams Avenue in Kensington. Although the sisters and their husbands invested in the area, they never lived here. Their presence was a brilliant marketing strategy, drawing attention to what was known as the 'Movie Girl Subdivision.'"

The Birth of Talmadge, San Diego

Talmadge wasn't just another real estate project; it was cleverly marketed using the allure of Hollywood. Developers capitalized on the fame of the Talmadge sisters, naming streets after them to attract buyers. This connection between San Diego and the entertainment world lent the area a sense of glamor and exclusivity.

Henson highlights, "During the Great Depression, the neighborhood thrived due to the homebuilders who lived and worked here. The area also boasts several important historical features, such as the first house built by renowned architect Cliff May on Norma Drive, and the first FHA loan-guaranteed house in San Diego, built by Louise Severin."

Talmadge Neighborhood Today

Over the years, Talmadge has evolved into one of San Diego's most charming communities. Known for its Spanish Revival and Art Deco architecture, much of the original 1920s and 1930s design has been carefully preserved. The neighborhood maintains a strong sense of community, with residents proud of its history.

"We'll be celebrating the 100th anniversary of the Talmadge sisters' involvement in the subdivision in 2026 with a big tribute," Henson shares.

Neighborhood events, from block parties to historical walking tours, often celebrate its past. As local historian John McLean put it: "There's something magical about walking down these streets named after Hollywood royalty. It's like you're walking through a living museum, with the stars themselves leaving a mark on San Diego."

Why the Talmadge Legacy Matters

Although the Talmadge sisters no longer hold the same star power they did in the 1920s, the streets named after them are a lasting tribute to their contribution to Hollywood's silent film era. Their fame may have faded, but their cultural impact remains, and their names continue to evoke memories of early Hollywood.

Henson notes, "Neighbors love learning about the Talmadge sisters. We even had a block party dedicated to them, where people wore 1920s clothing and posed with life-sized pictures of the sisters. Their legacy still captivates us, and their involvement is the reason our community exists today."

The Enduring Connection Between Hollywood and San Diego

The Talmadge neighborhood is a reminder of how intertwined Hollywood has always been with Southern California's identity. Though Los Angeles is synonymous with the film industry, San Diego has its piece of Hollywood history tucked away in Talmadge.

Embed from

As silent films gave way to "talkies" and the Talmadge sisters faded from the spotlight, their names remain. Henson concludes, "Although the Talmadge Sisters are the highlight of our history, we're working to also recognize the builders and architects who made this community possible during the Great Depression. Without the financial investment and promotion from the Talmadge Sisters, Talmadge Park would not be the vibrant community we cherish today."

Embed from

Sources:

Classic Movie Blog. "Constance Talmadge: The Carefree Queen of Silent Film Comedy." Accessed here .

Hollywood Archives. "Natalie Talmadge: A Hollywood Story Behind the Spotlight." Accessed here .

San Diego History Magazine. "The Talmadge Sisters and Their Connection to San Diego." Accessed here .

San Diego Reader. "Talmadge Neighborhood: A Hollywood Connection in San Diego." Accessed here .

Classic Hollywood Quotes. "Norma Talmadge: The Queen of Silent Cinema." Accessed here .

San Diego Film Archives. "Norma Talmadge: Remembering a Silent Film Superstar." Accessed here .